Lost in Translation: When Scientists, Regulators, and Industry Walk into a Bar... and Nobody Gets It.

Andrew Gruen, PhD
CEO, Working Paper
Senior Fellow, Future of Privacy Forum

Incentives ≠ Aligned

Gemini 2.5 Pro

This leads to (at least) three kinds of badness

  1. Technical solutions that are not actually implementable
  2. Legal interpretations that don’t survive contact with reality
  3. Social solutions that deeply misunderstand the incentives of the various actors

Things we tried and went wrong

Sadness ... not badness

  1. Medical federated learning
  2. Statewide Longitudinal Data Systems in Education
  3. DOGE for Good? (Easier access to benefits)

What do we do about this?

Lessons from the U.S. National Science Foundation's Research Coordination Network on PETs

Go register! https://fpf.org/pets

RCN?

  • Use cases -- to get real world examples around which we can coalesce
  • Experts -- to get actual implementation details and recommendations
  • Regulators -- to highlight areas where additional guidance is possible and would be beneficial

Use cases examined

  • Preventing Financial Fraud Across Different Jurisdictions with Fully Homomorphic Encryption
  • Hashed Linkages for Administrative Datasets
  • Measuring Digital Literacy with Telemetry Data Using Differential Privacy
  • Differential Privacy for End-of-Life Data

Next RCN Expert Call

Asking: what does delete mean? -- October 8

pets-rcn@fpf.org

Regulator Network

  • Global Network exclusively composed of DPAs/Regulators
  • Informal forum for authorities interested in exploring the nuances of PETs and their policy implications

    Over 110 representatives from 28 jurisdictions around the

    world
  • Bi-monthly online meetings and an annual in-person

    meeting, co-hosted by one of the Member authorities
    • Opportunity to learn about latest developments in the field,

      mainly from other Members, academia and policymakers
  • Bi-monthly newsletter covering key developments and projects in the field

Call to action

  • Certification Scheme for PETs Implementers (with a focus on overlapping PETs)
  • RCN like we are doing (come join us)
  • But also...

What else? This is what I want to talk about with you all!

Thank you!